Healthy Pumpkin Spice Lattes: Your Guide to a Blood-Sugar-Friendly PSL

Nothing says fall quite like a pumpkin spice latte (PSL). But the traditional PSL, with its heavy dose of sugar and syrups, can be too much if you are trying to watch your blood sugar. Enjoying the seasonal flavors you love without the sugar spikes that often come with them is possible. In this article, we’re bringing you blood sugar-friendly pumpkin spice latte options so you can savor every cozy sip.

{{mid-cta}}

Ingredients to Watch Out for in Your PSL

A classic PSL is sweet, creamy, and undeniably delicious—but it also packs in a lot of sugar, often up to 50 grams in a standard serving. Here’s a breakdown of the ingredients that can impact your blood sugar and how you can work around them for a healthier, more balanced version:

Syrups and Sugars

Syrups and sugars are where most of the carbs and calories come from in a PSL. Even a few pumps of pumpkin syrup can lead to major blood sugar swings. Instead, try using natural sweeteners like honey or maple syrup in moderation or a low-carb option like monk fruit.

Cream or Whole Milk

Traditional PSLs often contain cream or whole milk, which add more saturated fat. While there’s nothing wrong with saturated fat in moderation, particularly in healthy individuals, too much-saturated fat can increase the risk of abnormal cholesterol levels and heart disease. Using low-fat or non-fat milk or ultra-filtered, higher-protein alternatives is more blood sugar friendly. 

Artificial Pumpkin Flavoring

Commercial pumpkin spice lattes often use artificial pumpkin flavor instead of real pumpkin. Using actual pumpkin puree adds fiber, vitamins, and a richer flavor—perfect for a blood-sugar-friendly treat.

3 Healthy Pumpkin Spice Latte Recipes

Here are 3 recipes to satisfy your PSL cravings, each with a unique twist to fit different nutritional goals.

1. Classic Healthier PSL

This recipe gives you all the cozy flavors of a PSL without the sugar overload. Real pumpkin puree adds a rich, authentic flavor and boosts fiber and vitamin A, helping you stay fuller for longer and supporting your immune system as the weather cools down. 

With nonfat ultra-filtered milk as the base, this PSL is naturally low in carbs and calories, keeping it light and creamy without the need for heavy cream or whole milk. A non-nutritive sweetener like stevia, monk fruit, or sucralose provides just enough sweetness to complement the spices without spiking your blood sugar, making it a balanced, feel-good treat.

Ingredients

1 cup nonfat Fairlife ultra-filtered milk

1 tbsp pumpkin puree (unsweetened)

1 tsp pumpkin spice (or a mix of cinnamon, nutmeg, ginger, and cloves)

1-2 packets of stevia, monk fruit sweetener, or sucralose

1/2 tsp vanilla extract

Espresso or brewed coffee

Instructions

1. Heat the almond milk, pumpkin puree, pumpkin spice, honey or maple syrup, and vanilla extract in a small pot.
2. Once warm, blend or froth the mixture until it’s creamy.
3. Pour over espresso or coffee, and enjoy!

2. Protein-Packed PSL

Try this protein-enriched version for a PSL that satisfies and supports your muscle health. It’s low in sugar and contains an added protein boost. Protein keeps you feeling full and satisfied for longer and helps prevent spikes in blood sugar by delaying the digestion and absorption of carbs. 

Ingredients

1 cup unsweetened oat or almond milk

1 scoop vanilla protein powder

1 tbsp pumpkin puree

1/2 tsp pumpkin spice mix

Espresso or coffee

Instructions

1. Combine milk, protein powder, pumpkin puree, and pumpkin spice until smooth in a blender.
2. Pour the mixture into a small pot and heat until warm.
3. Combine with your coffee or espresso, and sip on a pumpkin spice latte that fuels your body.

3. Low-Carb/Keto PSL

Looking to keep carbs low without missing out on seasonal treats? This PSL recipe is keto-friendly, with no added sugars, so it’s easy on your blood sugar and fits seamlessly into a low-carb lifestyle. 

Combining unsweetened coconut or almond milk with a hint of pumpkin puree and warming spices like cinnamon, nutmeg, and cloves, this latte captures all the flavors you love in a PSL.

For sweetness, use a keto-friendly option like monk fruit, stevia, or erythritol. These add just the right amount of flavor without impacting your blood sugar. It’s the perfect drink to keep you energized and cozy, whether you’re relaxing at home or taking your favorite fall beverage on the go.

Ingredients

1 cup unsweetened coconut or almond milk

1 tbsp pumpkin puree

1/4 tsp pumpkin spice mix

1/4 tsp vanilla extract

Sweetener of choice (monk fruit, stevia, or erythritol)

Instructions

1. Warm the milk with pumpkin puree, pumpkin spice, vanilla, and sweetener in a small pot.
2. Froth or blend until creamy, then pour over coffee or espresso for a low-carb, satisfying PSL.

<div class="pro-tip"><strong>Learn More: </strong><a href=how-to-eat-pumpkin-seeds>How to Eat Pumpkin Seeds: 8 Delicious Ideas</a>.</div>

Tips for Making a Healthy PSL at Home

If you have pre-diabetes, diabetes, or are just being mindful of your blood sugar, you can still enjoy a pumpkin spice latte that satisfies your taste buds and balances blood glucose levels.

Go Easy on the Sweeteners

A little sweetener goes a long way! Start small, taste, and adjust as needed. Natural options like honey or maple syrup bring sweetness and add trace minerals, but low-carb alternatives like stevia or monk fruit work well for a zero-sugar option.

Use Real Pumpkin

Using real pumpkin brings a lot more to the table than just flavor—it’s packed with nutrients that make your pumpkin spice latte a bit healthier with every sip. 

‍Pumpkin is an excellent source of fiber, which supports digestion, helps keep you feeling full, and can even support stable blood sugar levels by slowing down digestion. Plus, pumpkin is rich in vitamin A, essential for maintaining healthy skin, vision, and a strong immune system. 

Along with fiber and vitamin A, pumpkin also contains powerful antioxidants like beta-carotene, which help protect your cells from oxidative stress and support overall wellness. You only need about a tablespoon in your latte to achieve that rich, authentic pumpkin flavor.

Try Plant-Based Milk for Fewer Carbs

Unsweetened almond, coconut, or oat milk are great choices to keep your latte creamy but low in carbs and calories. Plus, they blend well with coffee without adding lactose, which can sometimes cause digestive issues.

Final Thoughts

There’s no reason you can’t enjoy a cozy pumpkin spice latte and stay mindful of your blood sugar. With these healthier, homemade recipes, you can customize your drink to your taste and health needs, savoring each sip of fall in a way that works for you. Experiment with different flavors and ingredients to create your perfect PSL and enjoy a balanced treat all autumn long.

Learn More About the Signos CGM Program

Signos incorporates cutting-edge research and the proven power of continuous glucose monitoring. The data gleaned from the Signos app can help guide your health journey. Not sure if Signos is right for you? Take this quiz to find out! Interested in learning more about nutrition and healthy eating habits? Check out more articles on our blog.

<div class="pro-tip"><strong>Also Read: </strong><a href=pumpkin-health-benefits>Unlocking Pumpkin's Power: 8 Health Benefits</a>.</div>